| Code compliance and pressure-vessel documentation | 15% | Confirm that the boiler design, construction, inspection, and documentation meet the codes and jurisdictional requirements for its intended service. In the United States, ASME BPVC Section I generally covers power boilers, while Section IV covers heating boilers; applicability depends on the equipment and installation. | Applicable code stamps or certifications, inspection records, nameplate details, and a written statement identifying the governing code and jurisdiction. |
| Capacity and operating-pressure fit | 12% | Check rated steam output and allowable operating pressure against the actual load profile, peak demand, turndown needs, and system design. Compare ratings using consistent units and stated operating conditions. | Certified rating data, pressure limits, capacity tables, and performance information across the expected load range. |
| Fuel and burner compatibility | 12% | Verify compatibility with the site’s natural-gas supply pressure and fuel specification. Where required, confirm whether the burner supports a specified alternate fuel and what conversion or additional equipment would be needed. | Burner data, permitted fuel specifications, required gas pressure and flow, and any documented conversion requirements. |
| Thermal efficiency and test basis | 12% | Compare efficiency figures only when the calculation method, fuel heating-value basis (HHV or LHV), steam conditions, feedwater temperature, and operating load are stated consistently. Consider expected part-load operation as well as full-load ratings. | Test reports or clearly defined performance guarantees showing the test method, assumptions, and operating conditions. |
| Emissions and permitting suitability | 10% | Assess emissions relevant to the site’s permit and local rules, including nitrogen oxides (NOx) and carbon monoxide (CO), where applicable. Limits and measurement conditions vary by jurisdiction, equipment, and operating conditions. | Emissions guarantees or test data that state pollutant units, reference oxygen or other correction basis, load, and test method. |
| Controls, safety, and system integration | 10% | Review burner management, water-level protection, alarms, interlocks, control functions, and interfaces with the plant control system. Confirm that the proposed configuration meets applicable safety requirements and the project’s operating philosophy. | Control and instrumentation drawings, functional descriptions, safety-device lists, and interface requirements. |
| Manufacturing quality and traceability | 8% | Evaluate documented quality controls, material traceability, welding procedures, inspection processes, and nonconformance handling. An ISO 9001 quality-management-system certificate is evidence of a management system, not by itself proof that a particular boiler design complies with product codes. | Current quality-system certificates where applicable, inspection and test plans, material records, and manufacturing quality documentation. |
| Service, parts, and technical support | 8% | Check local service coverage, support availability, spare-parts lead times, commissioning scope, and the availability of qualified technicians. Evaluate the service arrangement for the full expected operating life. | Service response commitments, parts lists and availability information, commissioning plan, and training options. |
| Maintenance and lifecycle cost | 7% | Compare expected fuel use, routine maintenance, consumables, inspection needs, and likely downtime over a consistent analysis period. Include assumptions such as annual operating hours, load profile, and energy prices. | Itemized maintenance schedule, recommended spare parts, warranty terms, and lifecycle-cost assumptions. |
| Delivery, installation, and project execution | 6% | Assess the proposed delivery schedule, installation responsibilities, site access and utility requirements, commissioning sequence, and coordination with other contractors. | Project schedule, scope-of-supply matrix, site requirements, commissioning plan, and a list of customer-provided services. |