| Part and process engineering | 15% | Design-for-manufacturing review, forming simulation where appropriate, risk analysis, and documented design-change control. | Helps identify forming, springback, material, and fit risks before tool release. | Reviews the part drawing and material specification, documents assumptions, and proposes measurable validation checks. |
| Die design and build capability | 15% | Die concept and layout, tool component specifications, build schedule, and examples of comparable tooling scope. | Tool design must match the part geometry, production method, press, and planned output. | Explains the proposed die type, critical features, maintenance access, and the basis for the quoted build timeline. |
| Press and line compatibility | 12% | Press tonnage, bed and bolster dimensions, shut height, stroke, feed method, and available line specifications. | Confirms that the die can be installed and run on the intended production equipment. | Checks all key machine interfaces against the receiving plant's press data before finalizing the tool design. |
| Quality system and traceability | 12% | Current quality-system certificate and scope, inspection plans, calibration controls, nonconformance process, and material traceability records. | Supports consistent tool build quality and controlled verification of stamped parts. | Provides verifiable records and explains how inspection results and corrective actions are managed. ISO 9001 certification may be relevant; verify the certificate and scope directly. |
| Tryout and dimensional validation | 12% | Tryout plan, sample-part inspection results, measurement method, corrective-action log, and agreed acceptance criteria. | Confirms that the die produces parts that meet drawing requirements under defined conditions. | Uses customer-approved drawings and measurement methods, records trial revisions, and obtains approval before production release. |
| Production readiness and capacity | 10% | Capacity calculation based on the agreed cycle, shift pattern, planned maintenance, staffing, and material supply. | Tests whether the supplier can support the program's forecast and delivery schedule. | Shows assumptions behind output commitments and has a documented plan for ramp-up and bottleneck management. |
| Tool maintenance and spare parts | 8% | Preventive-maintenance plan, wear-part list, recommended spares, repair process, and tool ownership and storage terms. | Reduces avoidable downtime and clarifies how production tooling will be supported over its service life. | Defines maintenance intervals, response responsibilities, spare-part lead times, and access to tool documentation. |
| Program management and communication | 7% | Named project contacts, milestone schedule, meeting cadence, escalation path, and change-request workflow. | Keeps engineering, tooling, procurement, and plant teams aligned from kickoff through launch. | Reports progress against milestones and communicates risks, decisions, and schedule changes promptly. |
| Total cost and commercial clarity | 5% | Itemized quotation covering design, build, tryout, modifications, freight, installation support, and exclusions. | Makes bids comparable and helps identify costs that may otherwise appear after award. | States assumptions, payment milestones, ownership terms, warranty coverage, and the process for out-of-scope changes. |
| Delivery and logistics risk | 4% | Origin, shipping plan, packaging method, customs responsibilities where applicable, and delivery contingency plan. | Helps assess timing, transport protection, and handoff requirements for the die and trial parts. | Provides a realistic delivery plan and assigns responsibilities for transport, documentation, and receiving-site coordination. |