| 1 | Manufacturing Capacity | 15% | Annual seamless-tube output, number of production lines, billet-piercing capacity, and ability to support repeat orders. | Audited production records, equipment list, factory inspection reports, and documented delivery performance for comparable orders. |
| 2 | Product Range | 12% | Coverage of carbon steel, alloy steel, stainless steel, structural, boiler, heat-exchanger, line-pipe, and mechanical tubes. | Current product catalogue, technical datasheets, available outside diameters, wall thicknesses, steel grades, and manufacturing processes. |
| 3 | Standards Compliance | 15% | Conformity with applicable standards such as ASTM, ASME, API, EN, DIN, JIS, GB/T, and ISO requirements. | Valid certificates, third-party inspection reports, heat-number traceability, mill test certificates, and standard-specific test records. |
| 4 | Quality Control System | 13% | Control of raw materials, heat treatment, dimensional accuracy, surface quality, non-destructive testing, and final inspection. | ISO 9001 certification, quality manuals, inspection and test plans, calibration records, internal audit results, and nonconformance procedures. |
| 5 | Testing Capability | 10% | Tensile, hardness, flattening, flaring, hydrostatic, ultrasonic, eddy-current, chemical-analysis, and impact testing where specified. | Laboratory accreditation, test equipment calibration certificates, sample test reports, and documented testing procedures. |
| 6 | Dimensional Accuracy | 8% | Control of outside diameter, wall thickness, length, straightness, ovality, and end condition within the ordered specification. | Dimensional inspection reports, gauge calibration records, tolerance data, and random inspection results from completed shipments. |
| 7 | Export Experience | 8% | Experience with international documentation, export packing, customs procedures, destination-country requirements, and overseas logistics. | Redacted shipping records, export compliance documents, packing specifications, customer references, and inspection certificates. |
| 8 | Industry Applications | 7% | Proven supply capability for oil and gas, power generation, petrochemical, construction, machinery, automotive, and water infrastructure projects. | Project references, application-specific approvals, technical case studies, and records demonstrating suitability for the required service conditions. |
| 9 | Delivery Reliability | 7% | On-time delivery rate, production lead time, stock availability, order tracking, and responsiveness to schedule changes. | Historical delivery statistics, production schedules, logistics records, order-status procedures, and verified customer feedback. |
| 10 | Commercial Value and Service | 5% | Total cost of ownership, quotation transparency, minimum order requirements, technical support, warranty terms, and after-sales response. | Itemized quotations, payment terms, technical support records, warranty policy, complaint-resolution data, and post-delivery service procedures. |