| Intended use | Floor, furniture, cabinetry, trim, or another surface; expected foot traffic, abrasion, and spills. | Choose a coating whose label specifically lists the intended surface and use. A product designed for furniture may not be suitable for a high-traffic floor. | Technical data sheet (TDS), application instructions, and stated interior or exterior use. |
| Wear resistance | Resistance to abrasion, scratching, and repeated cleaning. | Compare products only when the test method and conditions are the same. A Taber abrasion result under ASTM D4060, for example, depends on the specified wheel, load, and test cycles; a number alone is not a universal durability ranking. | Test method, test conditions, reported result, and any stated limitations in the TDS. |
| Water and chemical resistance | Resistance to water, household cleaners, food or beverage spills, and other expected exposures. | Check the manufacturer’s stated cure period before exposing the finish to water or cleaners. “Dry to touch” does not necessarily mean fully cured or ready for heavy use. | Application guide, recoat and cure instructions, and resistance-test details if provided. |
| Appearance and sheen | Available sheen, clarity, color change, and whether the coating may affect the substrate’s appearance. | Review a sample on the actual substrate. Water-based finishes are often selected to minimize color change compared with some solvent-based finishes, but the result depends on the formulation and substrate. | Sheen options, sample-board results, and any stated color or clarity information. |
| Light exposure | Expected exposure to sunlight or indoor UV through windows. | Do not assume every urethane finish is equally resistant to yellowing or color change. Ask for light-exposure data relevant to the coating and substrate. | Product-specific UV or color-change test data, if available; stated interior or exterior suitability. |
| Application conditions | Recommended temperature, humidity, ventilation, surface preparation, and number of coats. | Follow the product instructions closely. Temperature and humidity can affect drying and recoating, while inadequate preparation can undermine adhesion regardless of the coating type. | TDS and label instructions, including preparation, application, and recoat guidance. |
| Indoor air and handling safety | VOC content, required ventilation, personal protective equipment, and cleanup instructions. | “Water-based” does not mean zero VOC, non-toxic, or safe to use without precautions. Follow the label and Safety Data Sheet (SDS), especially during application and while the coating dries. | VOC content as reported on the product documentation, SDS hazard sections, and label precautions. |
| Environmental claims | Claims such as low-VOC, low-emission, or environmentally preferable. | Look for a defined claim, its scope, and supporting documentation. VOC limits can vary by location and product category; low VOC alone does not establish that a product has no emissions or no environmental impact. | Applicable local regulatory information, test method, certification details where relevant, and current product documentation. |
| Maintenance and repair | Cleaning requirements, compatible maintenance products, and ease of recoating or spot repair. | Consider the expected maintenance routine and whether future repairs require sanding or recoating an entire area. Test cleaners and repair methods in an inconspicuous place first. | Care instructions, compatibility guidance, and repair recommendations. |
| Overall comparison | Performance, appearance, application needs, safety documentation, and cost per finished area. | Compare the complete system—including preparation, number of coats, and cure time—not just the price per container. Use matched test conditions and product-specific evidence wherever possible. | Current label, TDS, SDS, coverage information, and written test or certification documentation. |