| 1 | Product and design capability | Available round-bottle shapes, capacities, neck finishes, pump styles, and customization options. | Technical drawings, component specifications, samples, and confirmation of which parts require new tooling. | Compare samples and drawings against the same product brief. |
| 2 | Dispensing performance | Dose consistency, priming behavior, pump return, and performance with the intended product viscosity. | Written test method and results from repeated dispensing trials using the customer’s formula or a representative test material. | Set product-specific acceptance limits before testing; compare results under identical conditions. |
| 3 | Evacuation and residual product | How much product remains inaccessible at the end of dispensing and whether the follower mechanism moves reliably. | A documented evacuation test using a defined fill quantity, formula, storage condition, and endpoint. | Compare measured residual amounts using the same test protocol. |
| 4 | Leakage and closure integrity | Leakage at the pump, neck, joints, or base during storage and handling. | A written leak-test procedure identifying sample size, orientation, duration, and pass/fail criteria. | Run the same agreed protocol on samples from each supplier. |
| 5 | Formula compatibility | Compatibility of product-contact materials with the formula, including potential swelling, cracking, discoloration, odor, or functional change. | Material declarations and a customer-led compatibility study using the actual formula and defined storage conditions. | Assess appearance and function against agreed criteria at each study interval. |
| 6 | Materials and documentation | Resin and component specifications, product-contact declarations, and traceability information relevant to the intended market and use. | Current technical data sheets, material declarations, and batch or lot identification records. Check regulatory suitability for the target market. | Confirm documents match the quoted design and actual supplied materials. |
| 7 | Quality management and inspection | Incoming, in-process, and final inspection controls; defect classification; corrective-action handling; and lot traceability. | Quality manual or process overview, sample inspection records, and applicable certificates verified with their issuer. ISO 2859-1 provides sampling schemes for inspection by attributes; sampling plans should be agreed for each order. | Review the inspection plan and records; do not treat certification alone as proof of product performance. |
| 8 | Decoration and workmanship | Print or coating appearance, color consistency, adhesion, scuff resistance, and alignment on the curved bottle surface. | Production-like decorated samples, approved color references, and agreed appearance and durability checks. | Approve a signed reference sample and define acceptable visual variation in writing. |
| 9 | Production capacity and delivery | Quoted production lead time, order minimum, available capacity, tooling schedule, and ability to meet the requested delivery plan. | A dated quotation, production schedule, capacity assumptions, and written confirmation of order-specific terms. | Compare like-for-like quotations and schedules; these terms vary by design, order size, and season. |
| 10 | Packaging and transport readiness | Protection against scratches, deformation, contamination, and transit damage; suitability of packing configuration for the shipment route. | Packing specification, carton or pallet details, and a shipment test plan appropriate to the distribution system. ASTM D4169 provides guidance for evaluating shipping containers and systems. | Review packaging samples and assess transit performance using a route-appropriate test plan. |