| Process and material fit | 20% | Ability to handle the specified base material, part geometry, finish type, appearance, and functional requirements. | Written process proposal, material compatibility review, sample parts, and confirmation of critical areas such as holes, edges, and recessed features. |
| Quality control and process consistency | 15% | Documented inspection steps, control of process parameters, handling of nonconforming parts, and consistency between production batches. | Quality procedures, inspection records, calibration records, corrective-action examples, and any applicable quality-management certification. Verify its scope and validity. |
| Coating thickness and coverage | 15% | Whether the supplier can meet the specified coating thickness and coverage requirements on the relevant surfaces and part geometry. | Thickness measurement method, sample inspection results, measurement locations, acceptance limits, and equipment calibration information. |
| Corrosion and performance testing | 12% | Tests should match the coating, intended environment, and customer specification. Salt spray testing is not, by itself, a direct prediction of service life. | Test method, exposure duration, acceptance criteria, and reports. ASTM B117 and ISO 9227 describe salt spray test methods; agree on the applicable method and requirements before testing. |
| Pretreatment and surface preparation | 10% | Control of cleaning, degreasing, descaling, masking, and other preparation steps needed for the specified finish and substrate. | Process flow, preparation checks, contamination controls, and samples demonstrating adhesion and appearance on the actual or representative substrate. |
| Traceability and documentation | 10% | Ability to link finished parts to relevant production batches, inspection results, material information, and agreed specifications. | Example batch records, certificates or declarations where applicable, inspection reports, and a documented record-retention process. |
| Capacity and delivery planning | 8% | Available process capacity, batch-size suitability, production scheduling, packaging, and ability to communicate delays. | Capacity plan for the quoted volume, sample production schedule, lead-time assumptions, packaging details, and contingency arrangements. |
| Regulatory and restricted-substance requirements | 5% | Conformance to requirements relevant to the destination market, product type, and customer specification. | Applicable declarations or test reports, identification of the standard or regulation addressed, and confirmation that documents cover the specific finish and process. |
| Quotation clarity and technical communication | 5% | Clarity of pricing assumptions, included operations, tooling or setup charges, packaging, lead time, and response to technical questions. | Itemized quotation, written specification review, defined acceptance criteria, and clear communication of exclusions or open technical points. |